Creating this thread to track what each person likes and dislikes that are available in FTB..
I would suggest listing an item and its associated mode in the format:
PRO:
Tanks - Rail Craft
Steve's Carts
CON:
A mod can maintain a list of pro-s can Cons in this first post.
Hmm, I'd like to see...
BuildCraft 3
ComputerCraft
EnderStorage
Forestry
Hats/Hatstand
Industrial Craft 2
Iron Chests
OmniTools
Portal Gun
Railcraft
Steve's Carts
ThaumCraft
I can think of more but I know I would want at least these
The thing I've found with a lot of these mods is that you will find gaps in one mod that another fills nicely, for me IC2 and BC3 are very easy to get my head around because I've got a lot of experience with them, Thaumcraft not so much as I didn't really play around with it (so that would be the new mod I want to play with), but if we're going to get an FTB server going you will want to have started with IC2 and BC3 early on to get resources.
I'm happy with just about anything, though I would say let's dump stuff that isn't finished (like XyCraft).
If we were on a PVP server I'd pick the Ampz Pack and blow stuff up
Quote from: Mr. Analog on August 20, 2013, 01:34:40 PM
though I would say let's dump stuff that isn't finished (like XyCraft).
Exactly, better to add those when they are functional than when only the resources and most basic parts exist to use up inventory space. I also think in some ways it is unnecessary to have two very similar mods if one has a much higher cost to reward than the other. IE solar panels that cost more to make or digging machines that are not sufficiently unique.
Did anyone actually spend time breading bee's with the extra bee's mod? Are there alternatives to the forestry mod machines in other mods??? Building all the work benches and tools for some of the mods that require special ones for sub components gets fairly complex.. Where as some mods can use the standard tools and benches but still require new recipes.
I almost got into bee breeding when I found out that I could use propolis to synthesize slimeballs. I opted for the Factorization method of creating them in the end (when I started I thought Factorization would be easy LOL). I never got into the tree breeding side of things but there are some interesting benefits to actually farming trees for biofuel (in the form of nuts).
The main headache I've suffered from in the past is power conversion, power storage and pipes that drop valuable entities. Power conversion was absolutely the worst, nothing says fun like building 2 or more sets of infrastructure to process material.
Quote from: Mr. Analog on August 20, 2013, 03:46:24 PM
The main headache I've suffered from in the past is power conversion, power storage and pipes that drop valuable entities. Power conversion was absolutely the worst, nothing says fun like building 2 or more sets of infrastructure to process material.
Could be limiting but maybe we should go with only one power system (outside of red stone)?
One power system would serve as a good filter for mods, and mods that can be powered through conversion could still be included.
I really hated trying to figure out all the wires and power pipes for the various mods.. I used one power type and setup conversions for some items that I really wanted from other mods... but did not build any power generation for those other mods.
Well, there is the Ampz modpack, it uses the Universal Electricity API, it uses mods I haven't played with yet:
http://ftbwiki.org/Ampz_Pack
The core mods I would play with though are IC2, BC3 and Forestry, all of which have different kinds of power and power conversion. Kind of getting back to the old days of Tekkit.
That said I want to have tons of crazy mods to see what cool stuff we can build.
Would be nice not to have two types of tin gears, 4 or 5 wrenches, 3 or 4 types of copper.
Different grinding machines that creat different dusts etc. IE less duplication and more universe consistency.
I think some of these things are tweak able at the per mod, IE rail craft adds harder recipes for rails or you can have the normal ones?
I can deal with these issues however I think based on experience with the current server these are areas we could tweak.
I think that's why I put OmniTools as one of my preferred mods, one wrench, one screwdriver, etc
Things got a bit confusing with the Thermal Expansion mod which contained a lot of machines comparable to IC2, those kind of things are confusing for sure. Especially when dusts behave differently than pulverized material...
Exactly, but as for the wrench in omni tools it didn't remove / replace the 4 or so other ones, they still existed.
Some interesting notes:
BC pipes are far less stupid than they were. They won't drop @%&# on the floor if theres another direction for them to go, if they hit the end, then they migh.
Logistics Pipes are back \o/
I think you should just look at the IC2 and BC mods as entirely separate entities. There is no real good reason to try and use them together. The only good way I know of conversion at the moment is using the steam generator in railcraft, but you need to power it with an industrial steam boiler. Not a cheap prospect.
I hear a "BUT!" coming, DON'T! just treat them separately and you'll be a lot happier. Want some IC2 machines? Make an IC2 room. Want BC machines? Make a BC room.
And as I mentioned before, at least for most ores, if three mods have copper, there will only be one copper in the game. in the off chance that you manage to make one kind of copper that doesn't match the common kind, it should be useable in place of the original kind. Some mods like to be stupid and use the forge ore dictionary for some things, but most times those mods are retarded anyhow.
Looks like we agree a custom mod pack is a good idea but we may have some differences on what should and should not be included.
Tom do you want to create a base list of what at a minimum you think should be included ? Then maybe we can vote in other mods.
Could do. There are some mods that I'd really like that others may not like... But yeah, I can setup a list of absolutely required mods (IC2, BC, etc).
Quote from: Tom on August 21, 2013, 09:09:27 AM
Could do. There are some mods that I'd really like that others may not like... But yeah, I can setup a list of absolutely required mods (IC2, BC, etc).
I think you have more background on which mods may or may not be very stable or get updates, so maybe create the base list of of the most useful stable mods, then highlight your list of extras..
Obviously we want lots of cool new stuff to play with, but Direwolf was kind of a everything and the kitchen sink style pack.
Thing is, I want to play with a lot of the new mods in there. And a lot of the old ones.
Quote from: Tom on August 21, 2013, 10:17:41 AM
Thing is, I want to play with a lot of the new mods in there. And a lot of the old ones.
lol, well it is only a suggestion.
Quote from: Tom on August 21, 2013, 10:17:41 AM
Thing is, I want to play with a lot of the new mods in there. And a lot of the old ones.
Same here haha
But I'm happy to try anything
ANYTHING?
My Wish list
Pro:
Iron Chests (sorting systems needed lots of storage)
Mystcraft (i liked dimensions)
NEI
Rei's Minimap
Tom do you want to propose a mod list?
I happen to have next week off and will be home for some of it so I think I will have some time to play for a change.
That would be cool yeah, like I say I'm up for just about any modpack so just let me know when the server is up and what pack I should use!
I'll try and figure stuff out this weekend. I've a bunch of @%&# to do :)
I dub thee Cyrus (http://youtu.be/0utXjbS0fg4)
"@%&# off! I got @%&# to do"
So is there still interest in doing this?
:D I'm getting the urge to game again :D
Heh. Yeah, I'm just a little short on time lately.
Understandible
Interest yes, time no.
How about ... MoonQuest!
http://yogscast.wikia.com/wiki/MoonQuest
We can finally visit the Cube ... I mean Moon!
Galacticraft has been a bit buggy.
Minecraft? Buggy? Say it ain't so!
The issue was it made the core idea of the mod at the very least annoying, if not impossible to use properly.
Damn, I thought for a sec you were saying that in Minecraft there was a moon-mod with a moon-buggy to drive around in.
Quote from: Thorin on October 19, 2013, 07:24:49 PM
Damn, I thought for a sec you were saying that in Minecraft there was a moon-mod with a moon-buggy to drive around in.
There is a moon mod. It's called Galacticraft, and you can even make an orbiting space station. There are /mobs/ on the moon. With space helmets. It's pretty cool. Creepers with space helmets. and torches don't work :-x
Yeah!
I thought I'd revive this thread because minecraft machines
So is anyone else interested in something like this or just me? :D
It's tempting. but I don't want to be the one to go to the moon to delete the flowers.
Quote from: Tom on October 23, 2013, 10:28:31 AM
It's tempting. but I don't want to be the one to go to the moon to delete the flowers.
Hah, I saw that too lol
No I meant putting together a custom FTB pack, seems like a while since this was first brought up and with crappy weather coming I figured it's a good time to think about it again.
I'll see what I can do, but no promises.
:D