Well, i cant help by be a little disappointed at the current reviews being dished out by the critics. In some cases i cant help but agree after reading through the reviews (Madden 2006 on the 360 is like Madden 2006 Lite with nice graphics (they stripped out a ton of stuff)).
Anyways (5 reviews or more, data polled from GameRankings):
1. Call of Duty 2 - 91.4%
2. Project Gotham Racing 3 - 89.3%
3. Need for Speed Most Wanted - 84.4%
4. NBA 2K6 - 81.2%
5. Gun - 80.1%
6. Madden NFL 06 - 79.2%
7. Kameo: Elements of Power - 77.4%
8. NBA Live 06 - 71.0%
9. Amped 3 - 69.2%
..still no information on Perfect Dark, but Microsoft might have a review blackout till Monday (thats my guess). I was interested in Amped 3, but no longer.
I will probably be renting CoD2, NFS:MW, Kameo & Madden 2006. I will be buying PGR3 and PD0.
Microsofts first party titles Kameo and PGR3 seem to be doing well, and from what ive heard Kameo is rather shallow in that after 5 years of development its a shame that its only 8 hours long.